Cooking restaurant grade steak in your home is possible only with the right steak cut, seasonings, spices and the best frying pan for steak. Of all the frying pan materials, cast iron is the best in retaining heat to ensure that you get steak that is browned to perfection and evenly caramelized.
Cast iron needs to be regularly seasoned for good maintenance of the pan. The seasoning process of a cast iron frying pan over time allows steak to have great flavors and aroma no other frying pans can produce.
Why Cast Iron Works well for Steaks
With a cast iron frying pan you will get to enjoy steak that is perfectly browned on the outside as well as tender and juicy in the inside. Steak is exceptionally flavorful, too. With a cast iron frying pan you can cook steak just like steak masters do.
Here are the properties of a cast iron frying pan that makes it work well for steaks.
Good Conductor of Heat
A cast iron frying pan has a high heat capacity which is important when cooking steak. It produces a lot of heat from the surface through radiation. This means that the portion of the steak that gets into contact with the metal is not the only portion that gets cooked but also the portion of the steak above.
Retains Heat for Even Cooking
A cast iron frying pan retains the most heat of all cookware materials (similarly sized frying pans) and allows even cooking. When the frying pan gets hot, it remains hot and distributes heat evenly all through the pan. This is important when you are searing meat and for a consistently cooked crust.
Brings out the Flavors and Aromas
Adding a layer of oil after cleaning the frying pan to create a polymerized oil coating is perfect for browning and bringing out the best flavor of the steak the next time you use the frying pan. This seasoning process to maintain cast iron helps build flavors and aromas over time.
Oven Safe
Cast iron frying pans can be safely used in the oven. This is important when you are using the Reverse Sear (cooking steak first in the oven and finishing in the stovetop).
Non-stick
A well-seasoned cast iron frying pan will have a reliable non-stick surface. You will be assured that there will be no synthetic and harmful materials that will leak out from the pan just like with non-stick pans. This is important because steak is cooked in high heat.
Inexpensive
The manufacture of cast iron frying pans entails simple techniques making them basically cheaper than most cookware.
Health Benefits
The use of cast iron skillets provides some health benefits. Cooking in a cast iron skillet can increase by as much as 20% your iron content. This is a relevant issue because iron deficiency is common in women.
Long-lasting
A cast iron frying pan is guaranteed to last for a very long time. The more you cook on this cookware, the better and more seasoned it becomes. Many have inherited cast iron frying pans from their parents or even grandparents.
Factors to Consider when Buying Cast Iron Frying Pans
Not all cast iron frying pans are created equal. Look out for these features when picking a cast iron frying pan for cooking steak.
Right Size
You will need a good amount of space when searing steak in a frying pan to allow steam to escape so you can have a properly browned crust. Since cast-iron is thick a 12-inch frying pan will actually have around 9 – 10 inches of cooking space, just enough for a piece of rib-eye.
Comfortable Weight
A cast iron frying pan is naturally heavy. These pans can weigh between 8- 10 pounds. Heavy pans are good for cooking steak because the thickness of the metal retains heat more efficiently and longer than thinner frying pans. Choose a weight though you are comfortable carrying.
Easy to Grip Handle
Since cast iron frying pans are heavy and can get really hot, they should come with long and rounded handles that are easy to grip. It also helps if the frying pan comes with a helper handle opposite the main handle to help out with the weight.
Mess-free Pour Spouts
You will need to deal with a lot of grease in your frying pan when cooking steak. Efficient and mess free pour spouts can help with easy clean-up after cooking.
Factory Seasoned
When a cast iron frying pan has been factory seasoned, it means that it has already been treated with oil and heat making it ready for use right out of the box. You can also opt to do the seasoning yourself as pre-seasoned cast iron frying pans tend to cost more.
Keep in mind these features and you will surely be able to pick the best frying pan for steak.
Proper Seasoning of Cast Iron
Seasoning your cast iron frying pan will make it a non-stick cookware. Seasoning also helps build the flavor and aroma of the steak you are cooking. While your cast iron frying pan will come pre-seasoned you will need to re-season it over time to prevent the risk of damage.
Here is how to properly season your cast iron frying pan:
- Heat the frying pan over medium to high heat.
- Dip a paper towel in some oil.
- Use a tong to wipe the surface of the frying pan with the paper towel.
- Continue wiping the surface until oil smokes and no residue is left on the pan.
- Repeat the process three times. Make sure the pan is slightly cool in between applications.
When seasoning your frying pan, it is best to use flaxseed oil. You can also use vegetable oil but definitely avoid using animal fats.
See Also : Best Oil for Popcorn
Proper Cleaning of Cast Iron
Cleaning a cast iron frying pan or skillet entails a process different from most other types of frying pans. Here is how to properly do it.
- Clean the frying pan immediately after cooking steak and while the pan is still warm enough to handle.
- Hand-wash the frying pan in hot water.
- Use a sponge to scrub off the remaining bits of food. You can also opt to boil some water in the frying pan to deal with food bits that have really stuck on the pan.
- Heat the frying over low heat to dry. You can also opt to thoroughly dry the pan with a towel.
- Apply a thin coat of oil on the surface of the frying pan.
- Buff off excess oil.
After cleaning, store your cast iron frying pan in a dry place.
Here is a list of some of the most recommended and highest rated cat iron frying pans or skillets for cooking the perfect steak.
| Product Name |
Image |
Quality |
Our Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12.5 inch) |  |
A+ |
|
| 2. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12 Inch) |  |
A++ |
|
| 3. Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron Skillet (11-3/4-Inch) |  |
A+ |
|
| 4. Tramontina Enameled Cast Iron Covered Skillet, (12-Inch) |  |
A- |
1. Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12.5 inch)
Via: Amazon.com
The Utopia Kitchen is a popular brand of superior quality kitchen cookware. The Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet is great for first time cast iron cookware users.
Heat Conduction and Retention
This 12.5 inch cast iron skillet heats up fast and comes with excellent heat retention capabilities. These ensure even heat distribution allowing your steak to be perfectly cooked inside and out.
Design andConstruction
This Utopia Kitchen skillet comes with a heavy duty base and a smooth cooking surface to allow an evenly cooked steak.
It includes two handles – one long handle and an opposite helper handle to make carrying and lifting the skillet so much easier. It also comes with two spouts for easy pouring of excess cooking oil.
It features a cooking surface with high quality fine grain to create a non-stick patina in the long term to ensure steak does not steak to the pan.
It also comes with a keyhole in the long handle for hanging allowing for easy display and storage.
Size and Weight
This round frying pan is 17 x 12.5 x 2.3 inches for a spacious cooking surface. It weighs 7.94 pounds making it durable.
Seasoning
This frying pan comes pre-seasoned out of the box. The factory pre-seasoning process allows the natural polymers of cast iron to create an initial seasoning layer giving the skillet its high heat conductivity, even heat distribution and non-stick surface ideal for cooking steak.
Cooking Surface
This frying pan can be used on gas, induction, electric, ceramic-glass top stoves. It can also be used in campfires. This makes this pan highly versatile.
Cleaning andMaintenance
This frying pan can easily be cleaned hand-washed with soapy water after it has completely cooled. Re-seasoning after a few uses is recommended. Rub some oil on the cooking surface and wipe it clean with paper towels or soft cloth. It is also dishwasher safe.
Pros
- Solid cast iron construction for durability
- Excellent retention of heat for even cooking
- Spacious cooking surface to allow steak to cook to perfection
- thumbs-upCan be used on a stovetop, oven and on a campfire for versatity
- thumbs-upPre-seasoned so you can immediately cook steak out of the box
- thumbs-upDurable handles that will not detached even after long years of use
- thumbs-upComes with maintenance and care instructions to keep pan always in top shape
Cons
- Uneven and rough cooking surface
The Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12.5 inch) comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
2. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12 Inch)
Via: Amazon.com
Lodge is a favorite cookware of leading chefs. The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12 Inch) should be a part of your cookware entourage if you are a huge steak fan.
Heat Conduction and Retention
This skillet offers superb heat retention and even heat distribution to ensure steak is done to perfection inside and out.
Design and Construction
As it is a cast iron skillet, it is heavy so it comes with two handles (a helper handle and on the opposite a built-in handle with a removable red silicone holder) to make carrying and lifting easy. The silicone holder protects your hand from burning because cast iron can really get hot. It also comes with two spouts for easy pouring of excess oil.
Size and Weight
This round frying pan weighs 8 pounds and is 18 inches x 12 inches x 2.2 inches to allow an ideal cooking space for your steak.
Seasoning
This Lodge Cast Iron Skillet comes pre-seasoned from the factory with vegetable oil and baked for a black patina. Seasoning is to make the cooking surface non-stick and to enhance the flavor of your steak or any food you are cooking.
Cooking Surface
This cast iron skillet by Lodge can be used on the stove, oven, induction cooker, grill and open flame making it a versatile frying pan.
Maintenance
Wash the skillet with warm soapy water after each use. Re-season every so often to maintain its excellent cooking ability. Always store the skillet dry to keep it from rusting.
Pros
- Even heat cooking and excellent heat retention for a perfectly cooked steak
- Pre-seasoned so you can immediately cook steak after unboxing.
- Versatile cooking pan which can be used in stove tops, induction cookers and open flame
- thumbs-upComes with two handles for easy carrying and lifting
- thumbs-upComes with a removable silicone handle covers so you will not burn your hands while cooking.
- thumbs-upIncludes easy pouring spouts for mess free cooking.
Cons
- Not dishwasher safe
- Comes with a rough surface
The Utopia Kitchen Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12.5 inch) comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
3. Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron Skillet (11-3/4-Inch)
Via: Amazon.com
The Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron Skillet (11-3/4-Inch) is made by one of the most well- known cast iron cookware manufacturers. This skillet comes in an attractive Caribbean color.
Heat Conduction and Retention
This enameled cast iron skillet boasts of high cooking performance offering high heat conductivity, even heat distribution and superb heat retention to allowing the cooking of a perfect steak.
If you are a steak lover, this cast iron skillet can produce a crispy brown crust with a tender and juicy interior. Searing steak is a piece of cake with this skillet. It can also do slow cooking, stir frying and even bake cake.
Design and Construction
This enameled cast iron skillet is individually cast in sand molds and are individually casted to ensure superior quality an durability.
This skillet comes with an integrated iron handle and helper handle providing an easy grip for easy carrying and lifting. It also comes with a pouring spout for mess free pouring.
It is ideal for all cooking styles. It vibrant color can match any style of kitchen. It is beautiful enough to go from stovetop to dining table.
Size and Weight
Being cast iron, this skillet at 7.5 pounds is quiet heavy. It has dimensions of 13.2 inches x 11-3/4-Inches x 1.7 inches for an ideal cooking space.
Seasoning
This cast iron enameled cast iron skillet does not require any seasoning. The slightly abrasive satin black enamel cooking surface will develop a natural patina after you have been using it for some time making it all the more ideal for frying and searing.
Cooking Surface
Cast iron cookware is specially designed for use in high temperatures. This skillet can therefore be used in the stovetop, induction, broiler, grill and oven no matter how high or low the temperature is.
Cleaning and Maintenance
This skillet can only be hand-washed with soapy water. The enamel coating makes this skillet easier to clean. While it is also dishwasher safe, frequent dishwasher usage can dull the skillet’s finish.
Pros
- Solid and durable cast iron construction to ensure long years of use.
- Superb even heat distribution and excellent heat retention for even cooking of steak inside and out.
- Does not require seasoning because of the black enamel interior finish for easier care and maintenance.
- thumbs-upSpacious cooking area allowing steak to cook well
- thumbs-upDurable iron handle and helper handle to ensure they will not detach from the frying pan.
- thumbs-upCan be used from stovetop to dining table to eliminate the need to having to separately plate the steak.
- thumbs-upAttractive exterior Caribbean enamel exterior allowing it to blend well with the interiors of your kitchen.
Cons
- Some food tend to stick on the cooking surface
- Expensive
The Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron Skillet (11-3/4-Inch) comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
4. Tramontina Enameled Cast Iron Covered Skillet, (12-Inch)
Via: Amazon.com
Tramontina Enameled Cast Iron Covered Skillet, (12-Inch) comes with a gradated cobalt blue exterior finish.
Heat Conduction and Retention
This cast iron skillet provides excellent heat retention as well as slow and even heat distribution ensuring perfectly cooked steak with a beautiful brown crust and a juicy and tender inside.
Design and Construction
This 12-Inch cast iron skillet combines modern style and an old-fashioned charm. It comes with a lid to seal in the flavor of steak and any food. It comes with a flat bottom and heavy duty construction for even heat cooking and durability. It also features a tight fitting lid with condensation ridges to keep food moist and prevents the escape of natural flavors.
This frying pan comes with a long handle and a smaller one for easy carrying and lifting. It also comes with two pouring lips for mess-free and easy pouring of sauces and steak drippings. It likewise features superior non-stick ability.
This enameled cast iron skillet features a cooking surface in smooth matte black porcelain enamel. Its porcelain enamel coated lid comes with a stainless steel knob.
Size and Weight
This cast iron skillet coated with porcelain enamel is 19.4 inches x 12 inches x 4.5 inches and weighs 12.58 pounds for an ideal cooking space for steak.
Cooking Surface
This frying pan can be used in all cooktops for versatility. It is also oven-safe up to 450°F.
Cleaning and Maintenance
The heavy duty cast iron interior of this frying pan is coated with smooth enamel making it easy to clean with hot soapy water. The enamel coated exterior finish can be cleaned with soapy water, too. This skillet is not dishwasher safe.
Pros
- Durable cast iron construction allowing long years of use.
- Gradated cobalt blue porcelain enamel exterior finish for. form and function
- Tight fitting lid with self-basting condensation ridges to lock in moisture and flavor of food
- thumbs-upTwo durable handles for easy carrying
- thumbs-upEven heat distribution and good heat retention to allow a perfectly cooked steak.
- thumbs-upFlat bottom
Cons
- Not very thick cast iron material
- Skillet and lid are too heavy
- Not pre-seasoned
- Not dishwasher safe
- Some food tend to stick to the porcelain enamel cooking surface
The Tramontina Enameled Cast Iron Covered Skillet comes with a lifetime warranty.
Conclusion
Cast iron is a great cookware material. It can cook your steak to perfection producing a nice brown crust and tender and juicy inside. It is also a cookware that you can hand on to your children and grandchildren.
The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (12 Inch) is the surefire winner of the 4 cast iron frying pans or skillets reviewed. The silicone handle is perfect to prevent a burning hand as cast iron can really get very hot. It is non-sticky and it is easy to clean and maintain.
Lodge has a well-known reputation of manufacturing superior quality cast iron skillets with excellent heating performance. You can do all types of cooking in this skillet in your kitchen or even over your campfire.
The versatility and superior cooking performance of this skillet makes it the best frying pan for steak.